Chapter 8

The First Warning

The rain had finally stopped by morning, but Ashwood still felt heavy beneath a blanket of gray clouds.

Nia hadn’t slept.

Every time she closed her eyes, she heard Tanya’s voice crackling through the cassette recorder.

“If something happens…”

The unfinished sentence echoed louder than any confession.

She showered, dressed, and slipped Tanya’s letter, the prayer list, and her notebook into a weathered leather satchel before heading toward the courthouse. Her editor wanted an update on the corruption investigation, but Nia’s mind was no longer on judges or politics.

It was on a nineteen-year-old woman who seemed to have vanished without leaving a trace.

The courthouse parking garage was unusually quiet.

Nia parked on the third level and stepped out, balancing a cup of coffee in one hand and her satchel in the other.

She froze.

Something white was tucked beneath her windshield wiper.

Not a parking ticket.

An envelope.

No postage.

No name.

Only one word written across the front.

NIA

Her pulse quickened.

She looked around the garage.

A few cars.

An empty stairwell.

No people.

No movement.

She carefully opened the envelope.

Inside was a single sheet of paper.

Typed.

No signature.

No fingerprints she could see.

Only six words.

STOP ASKING ABOUT TANYA.

Below the warning was a second sentence.

Some stories bury the people who tell them.

Nia felt the blood drain from her face.

This wasn’t a prank.

Someone knew exactly what she was investigating.

She photographed the note before slipping it into a plastic evidence sleeve.

Then she noticed something else.

The coffee in her hand suddenly tasted bitter.

She looked down.

The plastic lid had been removed and replaced.

Her stomach tightened.

She hadn’t noticed.

She immediately threw the cup into a nearby trash can.

Maybe it was nothing.

Maybe it wasn’t.

She wasn’t willing to find out.

Inside the courthouse newsroom, Harold Bennett studied the note in silence.

“They’re escalating.”

“I know.”

“The first message warned you.”

He pointed to the latest one.

“This one threatens you.”

Nia nodded.

“They’re afraid.”

“Or desperate.”

Harold reached for his phone.

“I’m calling the sheriff.”

“No.”

He stared at her.

“You’ve received anonymous threats.”

“And if the sheriff is connected?”

Harold didn’t answer.

That possibility hadn’t occurred to him.

It had occurred to Nia.

More than once.

She spent the afternoon reviewing courthouse security footage with permission from the building manager.

Camera One showed the parking entrance.

Camera Two covered the elevators.

Camera Three overlooked the third floor where her vehicle had been parked.

At 8:17 a.m., a man wearing a gray baseball cap walked confidently toward her SUV.

His face remained hidden beneath the brim.

He slipped the envelope beneath her windshield wiper.

Then, before leaving, he paused.

Slowly…

He looked directly into the security camera.

As though he wanted whoever watched the footage to know he wasn’t afraid.

Seconds later he disappeared into the stairwell.

“Can you zoom in?”

The technician enlarged the image.

The resolution blurred immediately.

His face remained impossible to identify.

But one detail stood out.

A silver ring.

Large.

Square.

Decorated with an engraved cross.

Nia had seen it before.

She just couldn’t remember where.

That evening she stopped by Carter Grove Missionary Baptist Church.

The sanctuary was empty except for the custodian vacuuming the center aisle.

As she walked past the front pews, something caught her attention.

A display case near the fellowship hall.

Inside rested photographs documenting nearly eighty years of church history.

Pastors.

Choirs.

Mission trips.

Deacons.

She leaned closer.

There it was.

The annual Board of Deacons photograph.

Every man wore the same square silver ring.

The one she’d seen on the security footage.

She quickly photographed the display with her phone.

The custodian looked up.

“Can I help you?”

“I’m looking for information about the deacons who served here in the late nineties.”

The man hesitated.

“Most of them are gone now.”

“Gone?”

“Some passed away.”

“And the others?”

“They stopped coming.”

“Do you have a list?”

He glanced nervously toward the church office.

“Mrs. Holloway keeps the old records.”

“Can I speak with her?”

“She left an hour ago.”

Before walking away, he quietly added,

“If I were you…”

He stopped himself.

“What?”

He lowered his voice.

“I wouldn’t ask too many questions about those years.”

“Why?”

He simply shook his head and returned to vacuuming.

Night had fallen by the time Nia reached her motel.

Something immediately felt wrong.

The door to her room was slightly open.

She knew she had locked it.

Her heartbeat quickened.

She reached into her purse and wrapped her fingers around the small canister of pepper spray she carried on assignments.

Slowly, she pushed the door open.

The room appeared untouched.

The television remained off.

The bed was still made.

Nothing looked disturbed.

Until she reached the desk.

Her laptop was still there.

Her camera remained exactly where she’d left it.

Her wallet sat untouched.

But Tanya’s cassette tape…

Was gone.

Only the empty evidence sleeve remained.

Beside it lay another typed note.

YOU WERE WARNED.

Nia stood perfectly still.

Whoever had entered her room hadn’t been looking for money.

Or electronics.

Or jewelry.

They knew exactly what they wanted.

The tape.

The only recording of Tanya’s voice.

Someone wasn’t trying to rob her.

They were trying to erase Tanya.

Again.

As Nia stared at the note, her phone vibrated.

An unknown number.

She answered cautiously.

“Hello?”

For several seconds…

Only breathing.

Then a man’s voice, low and calm.

“You should’ve let her stay forgotten.”

The line went dead.

Nia slowly lowered the phone.

For the first time since finding Tanya’s photograph, the investigation had crossed an invisible line.

This was no longer a search for the truth.

It had become a race against someone determined to destroy it.

End of Chapter Eight

Enjoying this chapter?

Sign in to leave a review and help Oscar J. improve their craft.