Chapter 4

What Valentina Knows

Elena couldn't stop thinking about the photographs.

She lay in bed with the brass key on her nightstand, turning the images over in her mind. The shipping routes. The bank statements. The map with its red-marked sections spreading across the city like a disease.

She had expected to feel afraid.

Instead, she felt something closer to clarity. Like a lens had been adjusted, and the blurred edges of the world she'd been living in had finally sharpened into focus.

She went to work the next evening.

The club was busier than usual. A group of men in expensive suits occupied the back booth, speaking in low voices. Two women sat at the far end of the bar, drinking champagne and pretending not to watch the door.

Elena poured. She smiled. She wiped down the counter.

She was good at this — the performance of normalcy. She had been doing it her whole life.

At ten o'clock, Valentina walked in.

Same red dress. Same heels. Same way of moving through a room like she was the only person in it who mattered.

She sat at the bar.

"Vodka."

Elena poured it.

Valentina drank half of it in one swallow, then set the glass down and looked at Elena with an expression that was almost — almost — sympathetic.

"He showed you the office."

It wasn't a question.

"How do you know?"

"Because you look different. Everyone looks different after the office." Valentina turned her glass slowly. "The first time I saw those files, I didn't sleep for three days."

Elena studied her.

"How long have you known Dante?"

"Since we were children. Our fathers did business together. I grew up in this world the way you grow up in a house — you don't choose it, you just wake up inside it one day and realize the doors are locked."

"Are you—"

"No." Valentina cut her off before she could finish. "Whatever you're about to ask, no. Dante and I are not together. We have never been together. We are something worse than together."

"What's worse than together?"

"Bound."

The word sat between them.

"Our families made an agreement when we were young. I would marry into the Moretti family. Dante would inherit. Together, we would unite two empires." She finished her vodka. "That was the plan."

"What happened?"

"Dante happened. He refused. Told his father he would rather burn the empire down than marry someone he didn't choose." A thin smile. "Vincent was furious. But Dante is the only son. What was he going to do — disown his heir?"

Elena processed this.

"So you're not—"

"I'm not his fiancée. I'm not his lover. I'm not his enemy." Valentina leaned forward. "I'm the woman who was supposed to be all three, and ended up being none. That makes me something far more dangerous."

"What?"

"Someone who understands him."

Elena felt the weight of that.

"You said there was a girl before me. Someone who got curious."

Valentina's expression shifted. Something moved behind her eyes — not pain, exactly, but the memory of pain. The scar tissue of it.

"Sofia."

"What happened to her?"

"She worked here. Behind this bar, actually. About two years ago. She was — bright. Quick. The kind of person who notices things other people miss." Valentina paused. "Sound familiar?"

Elena said nothing.

"Dante noticed her the same way he noticed you. The watching. The conversations that felt like tests. The slow pull into the back rooms, the files, the truth."

"And then?"

"And then she disappeared."

"Disappeared how?"

"One night she was here. The next morning she wasn't. Her apartment was empty. Her phone was disconnected. No note. No goodbye. Nothing."

"Did Dante—"

"I don't know what Dante did." Valentina's voice was careful. Measured. "I know what I saw. I saw a girl who got too close, and then I saw an empty bar stool. Draw your own conclusions."

Elena's hands were steady on the counter. She made them stay that way.

"Why are you telling me this?"

"Because nobody told Sofia."

The words hit harder than anything Valentina had said before.

"I watched it happen," Valentina continued. "I watched her fall into his orbit the same way you're falling now. I told myself it wasn't my problem. She was a bartender. She was temporary. She would figure it out or she wouldn't." She looked at Elena. "She didn't."

"I'm not Sofia."

"No. You're not. Sofia was afraid of him. You're not afraid of him. That's what makes this worse."

Valentina stood.

"One more thing."

"What?"

"There's a photograph. Behind the bar, in the storage room, taped to the inside of the supply cabinet. Marco doesn't know it's there. Sofia left it."

"A photograph of what?"

"Of her. So someone would remember she existed."

Valentina smoothed her dress. She placed a folded bill on the bar — far more than the vodka cost.

"Be careful, Elena. Not of Dante. Of yourself. The most dangerous thing in this building isn't the man with the gun. It's the woman who stays anyway."

She walked away.

Elena watched her disappear into the private section.

Then she looked toward the storage room door.

She told herself she wouldn't go.

She lasted eleven minutes.

The storage room was small and cold, lined with shelves of bottles and boxes of cocktail napkins. Elena found the supply cabinet in the back corner. She opened it.

Inside: cleaning supplies, spare glasses, a box of swizzle sticks.

She ran her hand along the inside of the door.

Her fingers found the edge of something taped to the metal.

She peeled it off.

A photograph. Polaroid. Slightly faded.

A woman stood behind the bar — this bar — wearing the same black apron Elena wore every night. She was smiling. Dark hair. Dark eyes. A face that was striking in its openness, in the way it seemed to hold nothing back.

Elena turned the photograph over.

On the back, in small handwriting:

If you find this, I was here. I was real. Don't let them tell you otherwise. — S

Elena stared at the words.

Then she looked at the photograph again.

And for the first time, she noticed something that made her go cold.

Sofia looked like her.

Not exactly. Not like a twin. But the shape of the face, the line of the jaw, the way the hair fell — it was close enough that if someone saw them side by side, they would ask if they were sisters.

Elena put the photograph in her pocket.

She closed the cabinet.

She walked back to the bar.

She poured drinks for the rest of the night with a dead woman's face pressed against her hip, and she didn't say a word to anyone.

At closing, she pulled out the photograph one more time.

She looked at Sofia's smile.

She looked at the handwriting on the back.

I was here. I was real.

Elena put it away.

"So was I," she whispered.

Enjoying this chapter?

Sign in to leave a review and help TheHaze improve their craft.